Seizing Federal Lands is Not the Solution to the Housing Crisis

Nation's Leading Native Organization Group Responds to Vance Debate Comments

New York NY (October 3, 2024) — Asked in last night’s Vice Presidential debate for solutions to America’s housing shortage, Senator JD Vance reiterated the Trump campaign’s proposal to seize federal lands to build housing. The following statement is from Judith LeBlanc (Caddo), executive director of Native Organizers Alliance and NOA Action Fund.

The Trump campaign’s proposal to address the housing shortage crisis by seizing federal lands for development poses an extreme risk to Tribal sovereignty, Tribal lands, and sacred sites.

In last night’s remarks, JD Vance suggested that we “have a lot of federal lands that aren’t being used.” This is a dangerous view of our precious natural resources. As Native peoples, we don’t see our lands, waters, and wildlife as something to be “used,” but nurtured, protected, and managed sustainably for generations to come.

Many Tribal lands are held in federal trust. What would stop the administration from seizing our lands for their for-profit developments? We’ve seen time and time again, our Indigenous lands and resources developed, destroyed, and extracted for corporate profit. It is the right of sovereign nations to determine the future and use of our lands. Enacting a policy of seizing federal lands for development ignores the federal government’s obligation to consult and coordinate with our Tribal nations on land management.

Our National Parks and National Monuments are also federal lands which were forcibly taken from Tribal nations. Tribal nations and Native communities have made progress in re-indigenizing National Parks to restore the history and caretaking of those sacred places. Great strides have also been made in the last four years in federal-Tribal co-management of federal lands, waters, and other resources. This federal-Tribal partnership has strengthened protections of sacred places for the benefit of everyone. This should be the future of all federal lands management.

It is an overreach of the federal government and a violation of our treaties and Tribal agreements to enact a policy of seizing federal lands for development.

About Native Organizations Alliance

The nation’s leading organization dedicated to building Native power. Through advocacy, capacity building, and campaign support, Native Organizers Alliance amplifies the power of Tribes, organizations, and grassroots movements to drive policy change in Indian Country. Learn more at nativeorganizing.org/.